Editor’s note: This story contains references to sexual assault.
Say what you want about Charlie Kirk. The slain conservative activist often talked a good game when it came to freedom of speech.
“Free speech is not just saying what you want to say, but it is having to hear things you don’t want to hear,” he said back in 2017.
Noble words. They are nobler still because they apply to everyone … well, except maybe those who say the “wrong” thing at the “wrong” time about the “wrong” person. So say what you want about Charlie Kirk. Just be prepared to pay the price for free speech.
Kimberly Hunt of Portland thought speech was free in this country. Certain restrictions apply, of course, but Hunt thought she knew what you can say without being hauled off to Human Resources. She was HR after all. She worked as a general human resources specialist for a large company in another state until moving to Portland under a cloud of death threats and harassment.
Kirk was shot Sept. 10 last year while debating public shootings in the United States. Afterward, Hunt created a video about him. She did it at home on her own time and posted it to her private Facebook page.
‘The video had nothing to do with my job’
“I essentially used Charlie Kirk’s own words against him,” Hunt told Street Roots. “I referenced comments he had made questioning whether Black pilots were qualified, Islamophobic remarks he had made and his position that if his own daughter became pregnant from rape at 15, he would want the pregnancy carried to term.”
A little more than a month after Kirk’s death, Hunt was fired from her job of four years.
“The explanation I was given was not that I had violated a company policy, but that the backlash had become too disruptive to the company’s operations,” she said. “That distinction has always mattered to me because the video had nothing to do with my job. I made it as a private citizen, outside of work.”
Her supervisor said the company would document her departure as a resignation to help her with future employment and that the company would not contest her unemployment claim.
“When I subsequently filed for unemployment, however, my claim was denied after the company represented that I had violated company policy,” Hunt said. “That was particularly disturbing given what I had been told when I was terminated.”
Hunt is not alone, goodness knows, and math verifies. Many people lost their jobs and faced other consequences for criticizing Kirk.
In the wake of his death, National Public Radio crunched the numbers and found more than 30 people across the country were fired, placed on leave, investigated or faced calls to resign because of such criticisms.
Now, a little more than a year later, some are still stinging from criticizing a man who marketed himself as a veritable paladin of the First Amendment.
‘I will not mourn someone who spewed hatred‘
Erin Gudge is one of them. She also learned about the price of free speech when she expressed her thoughts about Charlie Kirk on her private Facebook page.
“I will not mourn someone who spewed hatred in the face of grieving mothers the day their children were murdered,” she posted on Facebook the day after Kirk died. “I will not mourn someone who would have preferred my own child not exist. I will not mourn someone who was teaching young people that empathy is weak and that civil rights should not be afforded to all.”
That was a little too much free speech for Philomath, the community of 6,000 people in Benton County where Gudge chaired the local school board. So townsfolk exacted a toll. Gudge faced heavy blowback as irate people descended on school board meetings. She resisted the backlash at first.
However, less than a month later, she yielded to the town’s anger and stepped down as board chair.
“Because there isn’t a policy in place that allows my fellow board members to remove me as chair of the board, in a good faith effort to restore public trust, I will be voluntarily stepping down as chair of this board effective immediately,” she told her fellow board members during a special meeting Oct. 7 last year.
Gudge did not respond to Street Roots’ request for an interview.
During the same meeting where she stepped down, her fellow board members censured her for her initial comments.
“It’s basically a public hand slap, to put it very simply,” Vice Chair Tom Klipfel explained to another board member who didn’t quite understand what censuring someone meant. “It just says you shouldn’t have done this, shame on you, think better next time and we as a board condemn it and are disappointed.”
So far, at least as this article is being written, Gudge remains on the board — just not as the chair. Her term expires next June.
“I remain committed to serving on the board with honesty, respect and dedication in support of all students and staff in the district,” she said as she stepped down as chair.
In a statement to the community, Gudge said her post was set only to be shared with her Facebook friends. However, one of those friends posted it publicly, and it spread across the country. She apologized for her post and affirmed what she said are her core principles.
“Violence is never acceptable,” she said. “Freedom of speech is fundamental to our society. I believe in America, the Constitution and our electoral processes. All people are worthy of dignity and respect. Every child has a right to a free, accessible and equitable education. Children deserve safety at home and at school. They deserve strong support systems and access to quality food, healthcare and adults who love and celebrate them for who they are. Expanding and protecting rights improves everyone’s lives.”
She added she didn’t think her post promoted violence.
“I don’t agree that there is a correlation between not mourning someone and condoning gun violence or homicide,” she said.
‘An alarming, harmful and a wholly intolerant statement‘
Philomath resident Amanda Lindsey said in a written statement that comments like the ones Gudge made should never be tolerated whether they are expressed publicly or privately.
“This is an alarming, harmful and a wholly intolerant statement,” she said of Gudge’s Facebook post.
Ronnie Ogg, another resident, also submitted a written statement, saying “children in Philomath deserve to learn and grow in an environment that is safe, respectful and inclusive.”
Kirk had some thoughts of his own when it came to inclusivity and respecting others.
“Unity is a strength, diversity is not,” he said at a rally at Texas A&M University in April last year.
He also supported a ban on all immigration from developing nations.
“It’s time to ban Third World immigration, legal or illegal,” he posted on social media two months before he died. “We’ve reached our limit, and we have a huge cultural, educational, housing, financial and essential services problem to fix now because of it. We need a net-zero immigration moratorium with a ban on all Third Worlders.”
Diversity? Weakness, Kirk said.
“When you import a lot of people who don’t share your values, like we have been from Somalia and from the Third World, all of a sudden, they say, ‘Diversity is a strength.’ Is it really?” he said.
Former school board Chair Shelley Niemann said Gudge’s comment undermined “the principles of respect, empathy and unity our school district has strived so hard to instill and overcome (sic).”
Kirk had no problem overcoming empathy.
“I can’t stand the word ‘empathy,’ actually,” he said in 2022. “I think empathy is a made-up, New-Age term that … it does a lot of damage.”
Many people seem to have overcome respect as well. Gudge told board members her comments resulted in death and rape threats as well as stalking and doxxing. She added her mother received a message hoping “she would have to hear the sound of my neck snapping.”
She said it is “heartbreaking” that so many people now think she stands for hate and tolerates violence.
‘God’s perfect law on sexual matters‘
So just how did Gudge get it in her head that Kirk hated people like her child and wished such people didn’t exist? It might have been something he said.
Citing Leviticus 18, Kirk said in June 2022 that “God’s perfect law on sexual matters” includes stoning gay men to death.
However, he may have gotten his scriptures confused. Leviticus 18 may take a dim view of sexual relationships between men, but it doesn’t mention stoning or any other form of the death penalty. Leviticus 20 is another matter. It does impose the death penalty for several things, including disrespecting one’s parents.
Working on Sunday (Exodus 35:2) will also get a person killed under God’s perfect law.
‘The Kirkening‘
Hunt avoided an angry mob concerned with tolerance, empathy and inclusivity, but she told Street Roots the effect on her career has been, euphemistically put, difficult. “The Kirkening,” she calls it.
She never struggled to get job interviews before, but during the past year, she’s had only three interviews. The interviews seem to go well. She’s told to expect next steps. Then nothing.
“I obviously can’t know what happens internally after every interview, but when you search my name, the social media controversy and headlines surrounding my firing are part of what employers can find,” she said. “Given how dramatically my experience in the job market changed after the firing, I believe that public association has affected my employment prospects.”
The consequences go beyond the job market.
‘I don’t think losing my livelihood should mean losing my voice‘
“After my information was circulated online, I received what I would estimate to be around 100 death threats,” Hunt said. “At one point, a sheriff contacted me and told me they were aware that I had apparently been placed on some kind of ‘hit list’ and that patrols would be increased around my neighborhood.”
The threats compelled her to move to Portland a few months ago. She still doesn’t have a job. The only way she stays afloat financially is through a GoFundMe account, she said.
“Without that support, I genuinely don’t know what I would have done,” Hunt said.
So what would Hunt, as an HR professional, do if someone like her was referred to her office?
“It really depends on the circumstances,” she said. “As an HR professional, I’d first look at whether the employee made those statements while representing the company or clearly speaking as a private citizen. I’d also consider whether their conduct actually affected the workplace, violated company policy or involved things like harassment, threats or discrimination.”
Someone simply expressing a political opinion on their personal social media is very different from someone making those statements at work or on behalf of their employer, she added.
“Personally, I’m looking for companies that understand that distinction and respect that employees can have lives and opinions outside of work,” she said.
She continues to express her own opinions, regardless of the possible impact on her work life. She expresses herself on social media against the Trump administration and the conservative culture it has created. She was willing to flee to Portland but not from the political arena as a whole.
“Disappearing would ultimately reward exactly what happened to me,” Hunt said. “I lost my job after thousands of strangers pressured my employer over political speech I made in my own home, on my own time, and I then watched that moment follow me into nearly every aspect of my life.”
There were certainly moments when being quiet would be easier, she added.
“But I don’t think losing my livelihood should mean losing my voice too,” Hunt said. “If anything, going through this has made me more committed to speaking about the things I believe matter, even knowing firsthand that there can be consequences for doing so.”
This article appears in November 18, 2026.
